ASSESSMENT OF OCCUPATIONAL STRESS MENTAL HEALTH AND COPYING STYLE AMONG COLLEGES TEACHERS BASED ON SELECTED DEMOGRAPHIC ATTRIBUTES A CASE STUDY OF SOUTHERN DISTRICTS OF PUNJAB

http://dx.doi.org/10.31703/gssr.2023(VIII-I).28      10.31703/gssr.2023(VIII-I).28      Published : Mar 2023
Authored by : Muhammad Aslam , Muhammad Nawaz , Sumaira Kanwal

28 Pages : 309-321

    Abstract

    The current study investigated work-related stress, mental health and copying styles of college teachers based on their demographic attributes. A sample of n=176 (males=115; females=61) lecturers working at the college level was taken and surveyed. Self-structured questionnaires consisted of occupational stress, mental health, and copying style. When comparing two different groups, females were more likely inclined to stress and mental health as compared with males (p < 0.05). Married lecturers reported higher mean scores on mental as compared with unmarried lecturers (p < 0.05). The findings showed that there were no statistically significant changes in the research variables based on the participants' age, experience, or type of employment (p > 0.05), with the exception of copying style based on age (p 0.05). When organizing an intervention programmed to advance and promote mental health, these findings must be taken into account.

    Key Words

    Assessment, Occupational Stress, Coping, Mental Health, Demographics & Attributes

    Introduction

    In any aspect of life, a calm and pleasant environment is critical to achieving satisfying results. Peaceful competitive working conditions, mental readiness, and psychological well-being are all essential determinants of a peaceful environment. In a competitive environment, it is commonly noted that certain stressful conditions occur (Fard & Karimi, 2015). If, on the other hand, the difficult situation is under control from numerous angles, one may easily perform and expect superior results. If not, the situation requires careful evaluation and attention (Farooq-Abbasi, 2015).

    Natural or pure science has gained some traction in technological advancements such as missile and space technology. Similarly, exploratory activity such as archaeology or geology, where experimental work is valued, merits consideration to some extent. Furthermore, the establishment of a new, high-quality institution, as well as a favourable environment, is critical for the rest of the discipline and its application for the benefit of humanity in the country (Khan, Jabeen & Manzoor, 2020).

    Unfortunately, health, physical education, recreation, and sport have never been considered among the issues of "importance" in the majority of the East. The lack of interest or ignorance among the ruling class and academics seems to be the most significant factor in the area of physical education and sports, while there may be many other factors at play. The reason for this is that, even though we are in the first quarter of the twenty-first century, we do not see any shining personalities in the field of applied research from this region of the world (Khan et al., 2020). 

    Teachers may experience psychological, cognitive, and social shock as a result of the transfer from a BA/B.Sc. to a BS program, particularly in the area of Health and Physical Education because this educational change has substantial distinctions. Teachers will be confronted with new teaching methods as well as a new living environment. Teachers may feel various sorts of stress as a result of these changes, which may negatively impact their mental health. Academic pressures such as conducting and marking regular tests, assignments, projects, and other college obligations may be encountered by teachers in this BS degree. Teachers become stressed as a result of their incompetence or failure to meet these criteria.

    The availability of physical sports facilities like courts, fields, and track with playing equipment like Bat, Ball, Net, Shuttle, Racket, and other athletics and gymnastic activities, in addition to learning tools, transportation options, and other services offered on campus for students, can increase the stress levels of physical education teachers. Stress also has an effect on the physical and emotional well-being of teachers. For instance, teachers who experience high levels of stress perceive their own health as being worse, have low self-esteem, and are more prone to participate in risky behaviours (Acquadro et al., 2018). According to the stress and coping theory put forward by Lazarus and Folkman (1984), people are most susceptible to psychopathological experiences when they lack effective coping mechanisms. As a result, it was thought important and required to conduct an empirical study to identify and comprehend work-related stress, among college physical education professors.


    Objectives  

    1. To measure the occupational stress, coping style and mental health colleges’ physical education teachers. (Frequency and Percentage)

    2. To examine the significance of group mean differences in changing participants’ responses related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (Test of significance)


    Hypotheses 

    H1: There is a significant gender-wise difference related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (t-Test)

    H2: There is a significant marital status-wise difference related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (t-Test)

    H3: There is a significant age-wise difference related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (ANOVA)

    H4: There are significant teaching experience-wise differences related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (ANOVA)

    H5: There is a significant qualification-wise difference related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (ANOVA)

    H6: There is a significant nature of job-wise differences related to occupational stress, coping style and mental health. (ANOVA)

    Research Methodology

    Research Philosophy

    Two important problems are addressed by research philosophy: 1) What is knowledge, and 2) how can knowledge be documented and passed on? The positivist philosophy considers knowledge that may be objectively verified by observation. Furthermore, positivist philosophy implies that verifiable information may be documented and communicated using observable symbols like concepts and words (Babones, 2016). The researcher proposed positivist philosophy in light of these thoughts on research philosophy.


    Research Approach

    In social science research, a survey approach is often used to collect human perceptions, opinions, or positions on many subjects (Moser & Kalton, 2017). The current study was focused on the perceived stance of Physical Education Teachers (PETs); hence, a cross-section survey approach was employed to recruit participants using questionnaires. For such sociological studies, a survey is indicated as an ideal tool.

    Population and Sample

    Population

    A population is a group of individuals, things, or occasions that a researcher is interested in learning more about in order to provide data for some research topic. As a result, the research topic determines the population, with the researcher setting the boundaries of a particular population (Moser & Kalton, 2017). Physical education teachers at the college level in southern Districts of Punjab constituted the study's population.


    Sample and Sampling

    A sample is a subset of a population chosen for research. If a sample speaks for every segment of the population and all of its characteristics, it becomes representative of the entire population (Moser & Kalton, 2017). The information used in the formula originated from a pilot study that was carried out as part of the project planning stage to assess the questionnaire and gather some statistics for the formula to take into account when calculating sample size. The whole formula and the results of the computation are displayed in Table 3. The sample size was (n=176).

    Table 1

    Giving the Details of Sample Selection

    =((SD*SD)/(((E*E)/(Z*Z))+((SD*SD)/N)))

    SD

    Z

    E

    N

    n

    0.43

    1.96

    0.043

    324

    175.76

    Reliability and Validity of Data

    Reliability Statistics

    In statistics, reliability refers to a measure's overall consistency; a measure is deemed highly dependable if it produces similar results in similar conditions (Carpenter, 2006). Cronbach's alpha is a measure of internal consistency in terms of item affinity and association. Cronbach's alpha is a coefficient indicating dependability (or consistency), not a statistical test, in technical terms.


    Validity Statistics

    Validity is a criterion for determining whether or not the concepts employed in data collection are appropriate for measuring the data they are designed to collect. The validity test aids in choosing the types of tests to run on data in order to evaluate hypotheses (Carpenter, 2006). The researcher utilized 'Factor-analysis' to obtain evidence regarding the validity of data in accordance with common survey data validity criteria.

    Data Analysis

    Descriptive Tools

    Descriptive data refers to the study's individual variables. Tables were utilized to show descriptive statistics on the frequency of sample groups based on demographic characteristics, as well as a table of descriptive data on the study variables.


    Tests of Significance

    To assess the group mean differences based on the demographic characteristics of respondents, tests of significance (TOS) are performed. In the current study, the t-Test was used for two groups, while the ANOVA was applied for more than two groups. The age, gender, designation, qualification, and teaching experience of physical education teachers were tested in this study to see if there are any group means differences. The statistics for assessing the hypotheses were computed using T-tests.

    Results and Discussion

    This part of the research work presented the main results obtained after the application of statistical tests to test the set hypotheses and achieve the desired objectives as well. Therefore, the analysis and interpretation of data are presented. This chapter is categorized into various sections. It included both descriptive as well as inferential statistics to assess the research variables. 


    Demographic Attributes 

    The descriptive results described the frequency and percentage of demographic attributes as well as item-wise analysis of the questionnaires. The analysis of descriptive statistics helps in understanding the research variables under study. 

    Table 2

    Ages of the Participants


    The above table shows the frequency and parentage of the participants included in the study. Out of 176, 03 respondents were aged between 18-22, 07 respondents having aged between 23-27, 34 respondents showed their age between 28-32, 77 respondents marked their age between 33-37, and 55 respondents reported their age between 38-42. 

     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Age

     

    18-22

    3

    1.7

    1.7

    1.7

    23-27

    7

    4.0

    4.0

    5.7

    28-32

    34

    19.3

    19.3

    25.0

    33-37

    77

    43.8

    43.8

    68.8

    38-42

    55

    31.3

    31.3

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    Table 3

    Gender of the Participants



     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Gender

    Male

    115

    65.3

    65.3

    65.3

    Female

    61

    34.7

    34.7

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    The above table presented the gender-wise frequency and percentage of the participants included in the survey. Among 176 respondents, 115 were male at 65.3% and 61 were female at 34.7%. 

    Table 4

    Teaching Experience of the Participants



     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Experience

    1-5 Years

    10

    5.7

    5.7

    5.7

    6-10 Years

    18

    10.2

    10.2

    15.9

    11-15 Years

    67

    38.1

    38.1

    54.0

    16-20 Years

    47

    26.7

    26.7

    80.7

    21-25 Years

    34

    19.3

    19.3

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    The above table depicted the experience-wise details of the participants. According to the table, 10 respondents have shown their experience between 1-5 years, and 18 respondents reported their experience between 6-10 years. In the same table, 67 respondents have shown their experience between 11-15 years, 47 have marked their experience between 16-20 years, and the remaining portion consisted of 34 respondents who have shown their experience between 21-25 years.

    Table 5

    Marital Status of the Participants 



     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Marital Status

    Married

    136

    77.3

    77.3

    77.3

    Unmarried

    40

    22.7

    22.7

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    The table on the previous page indicated the marital status of the respondents. Among 176 respondents, 136 were married and 40 were unmarried.

    Table 6

    Education of the Participants 


    The above table presented an education-wise description of the respondents. As can be seen in the table, 38 respondents have a qualification of BS, and 87 respondents have shown their qualification of MA/M.Sc, 47 respondents have shown their qualification of M.Phil and only 04 respondents have shown their qualification of PhD.

     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Education

    B.S

    38

    21.6

    21.6

    21.6

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    49.4

    49.4

    71.0

    M. Phil

    47

    26.7

    26.7

    97.7

    Ph. D

    4

    2.3

    2.3

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    Table 7

    Designation of the Participants 


    The above presented that there were 176 respondents who participated in the survey. Among these 57 respondents were physical education teachers, 78 respondents were from Arts, and the remaining portion consisted of 41 respondents who were science teachers. 

     

    Frequency

    Per cent

    Valid Percent

    Cumulative Percent

    Designation

    Physical Edu. Teacher

    57

    32.4

    32.4

    32.4

    Arts Teacher

    78

    44.3

    44.3

    76.7

    Science Teacher

    41

    23.3

    23.3

    100.0

     

    Total

    176

    100.0

    100.0

     

    Frequency Distribution

    This section of the thesis deals with the frequency distribution of the response rate of each question given in the instrument for measuring an important variable of occupational stress. This distribution may help the readers to understand the nature of each item that how the respondents responded to the questions related to the measurements of occupational stress.   

    Table 8

    Frequency distribution of Occupational Stress



     

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    To maintain discipline and order in the classroom.

    176

    2.4034

    1.14731

    To work with unmotivated students.

    176

    2.7614

    .82107

    To work with agitated or unruly children.

    176

    1.7443

    .84682

    Carrying out school duties during the time dedicated to my family (e.g. reading and marking offhand papers at home).

    176

    2.0227

    1.06880

    To teach in noisy conditions (e.g. too much noise outside the street).

    176

    2.7273

    .85158

    To teach in unsuitable thermal conditions (e.g. too cold).

    176

    2.5739

    1.18813

    Supervise students during breaks.

    176

    2.6705

    .77418

    To work with papers or documents related to administrative activities.

    176

    2.6761

    .90881

    To make trips with students.

    176

    2.3636

    1.10254

    To prepare students for competitions outside of school hours.

    176

    3.0568

    .82612

    To prepare students for completion taking place during school hours.

    176

    3.0625

    .78672

    To have to reckon with my colleagues.

    176

    2.8295

    .90360

    To have an inspection of evaluating the situation in the classroom.

    176

    3.1932

    .69047

    To help a child with poor academic results to progress.

    176

    2.6705

    1.19256

    To permanently pursue progress in student acquisitions.

    176

    3.0227

    .67574

    Overall

    176

    2.6511

    .29601

    The occupational stress of the respondents was measured through several questions and their mean and standard deviation have been given in the above table. As can be seen in the table, there were 176 respondents who responded to the instrument. The overall mean value was found lesser than the hypothetical mean of 2.65 < 3.00. It shows that teachers at the college level are facing occupational stress. 

    Table 9

    Frequency distribution of Mental Health


    The mental health of the respondents was measured through several questions and their mean and standard deviation have been given in the above table. The overall mean value was found lesser than the hypothetical mean 2.95 < 3.00. It shows that teachers at the college level reported lower mental health. 

     

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    Makes appropriate noises when he should not

    176

    2.6932

    .69047

    Demands must be met immediately

    176

    2.8409

    .69094

    Overly sensitive to criticism

    176

    3.3466

    .65839

    Distractibility or attention span a problem

    176

    3.0398

    .70395

    Mode changes quickly and drastically

    176

    2.7500

    .83152

    Submissive attitude towards authority

    176

    2.9489

    .70322

    Restless, always “up and on the go”

    176

    3.0341

    .86782

    Excitable, impulsive

    176

    3.0398

    .81669

    Excessive demand for teachers' attention

    176

    2.8125

    .80290

    No sense of fair play

    176

    2.9148

    .71603

    Appears to lack leadership

    176

    3.4034

    .64302

    Childish and immature

    176

    2.8068

    .69870

    Denys mistakes or blames others

    176

    2.6932

    .69047

    Does not get along well with other children

    176

    2.8068

    .69870

    Uncooperative with classmates

    176

    2.6932

    .69047

    Easily frustrated in all areas

    176

    2.8409

    .69094

    Uncooperative with teachers

    176

    3.3977

    .64214

    Overall

    176

    2.9512

    .26118

    Table 10

    Frequency distribution of Coping Stress


    The coping strategy of the respondents was measured through several questions and their mean and standard deviation have been given in the above table. The overall mean value was found lesser than the hypothetical mean of 2.45 < 3.00. It shows that teachers at the college level reported a partial role in coping strategies for their occupational stress. 

     

    N

    Mean

    Std. Devi.

    I have been trying to work or other activities to take my mind off things

    176

    2.2670

    1.03771

    I have been concentrating my efforts on doing something about the situation, I am in

    176

    2.6477

    .88853

    I have been using alcohol or other drugs to make myself feel better.

    176

    1.7727

    .80324

    I have been getting emotional support from others.

    176

    1.8068

    .88619

    I have been taking action to try to make the situation better.

    176

    2.6477

    .88853

    I have been refusing to believe that it has happened.

    176

    2.6477

    .88853

    I have been getting help and advice from other people.

    176

    2.3295

    .99968

    I have been trying to see it in a different light, to make it seem more positive.

    176

    2.3295

    .98818

    I have been trying to come up with a strategy about what to do.

    176

    2.3068

    .96638

    I have been giving up the attempt to cop

    176

    2.5795

    1.04986

    I have been looking for something good in what is happening

    176

    2.6932

    .97814

    I have been doing something to think about it less, such as going to movies, watching TV, reading, daydreaming, sleeping, or shopping.

    176

    2.6477

    .88853

    I have been accepting the reality of the fact that it has happened.

    176

    2.5000

    1.06369

    I have been expressing my negative feelings.

    176

    2.3068

    1.02381

    I have been trying to find comfort in my religion or spiritual beliefs.

    176

    2.6875

    .88741

    I have been trying to get advice or help from other people about what

    176

    2.2330

    .91791

    I have been learning to live with it.

    176

    2.5852

    1.03295

    I have been thinking hard about what steps to take.

    176

    3.1818

    .85584

    I have been blaming myself for things that happened.

    176

    2.3182

    1.09592

    Overall

    176

    2.4512

    .30509

    Testing of Hypotheses Table 11

    Results of t-Test on Gender-based Differences  


    Variables

    Gender

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    T

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    Male

    115

    2.3745

    .23672

    -6.047

    174

    .000

    Female

    61

    2.6479

    .36021

    Occupational Stress

    Male

    115

    2.5587

    .25398

    -6.322

    174

    .000

    Female

    61

    2.8267

    .29193

    Mental Health

    Male

    115

    2.6263

    .25797

    -5.110

    174

    .000

    Female

    61

    2.8311

    .24329

    The fourth hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the gender of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed significant gender-wise differences in all the research variables including coping strategy, occupational stress and mental health. The p-values for all the variables were found lesser than the critical value (p < 0.05). It means that male and female lecturers reported differences of opinion regarding variables under study. Based on these results, the set hypothesis H4 is strongly accepted. 

    Table 12

    Results of t-Test on Marital Status-wise Differences  



    Variables

    Gender

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    T

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    Married

    136

    2.4818

    .32013

    .977

    174

    .330

    Unmarried

    40

    2.2467

    .28747

    Occupational Stress

    Married

    136

    2.6707

    .29471

    1.583

    174

    .115

    Unmarried

    40

    2.5868

    .29470

    Mental Health

    Married

    136

    2.7177

    .26313

    1.857

    174

    .065

    Unmarried

    40

    2.6280

    .28707

    The fifth hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the marital status of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed insignificant marital status-wise differences in all the research variables (coping strategy, occupational stress and mental health). The p-values for all the variables (coping strategies= .330, occupational stress= .115, and mental health= .065) were found greater than the critical value (p > 0.05). It means that married and unmarried lecturers reported no statistically significant differences of opinion regarding variables under study. Based on these results, the set hypothesis H5 is strongly rejected. 

    Table 13

    Results of ANOVA on Age-wise Differences  


    The sixth hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the age of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed significant age-wise differences in all the research variables except coping strategy. The p-values for all the variables except coping strategy were found lesser than the critical value (p < 0.05). Based on these results, the set hypothesis H5 is partially accepted. 

    Variables

    Age group

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    F

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    18-22

    3

    2.6467

    .16258

    .985

    171

    .417

    23-27

    7

    2.4286

    .33687

    28-32

    34

    2.5309

    .26047

    33-37

    77

    2.4271

    .29394

    38-42

    55

    2.4856

    .36581

    Total

    176

    2.4693

    .31306

     

     

     

    Occupational Stress

    18-22

    3

    2.4633

    .23094

    3.038

    171

    .019

    23-27

    7

    2.4000

    .18421

    28-32

    34

    2.5888

    .18666

    33-37

    77

    2.6539

    .30582

    38-42

    55

    2.7295

    .32617

    Total

    176

    2.6516

    .29597

     

     

     

    Mental Health

    18-22

    3

    2.4500

    .22716

    3.818

    171

    .005

    23-27

    7

    2.4200

    .16155

    28-32

    34

    2.6453

    .18113

    33-37

    77

    2.7095

    .27511

    38-42

    55

    2.7613

    .29392

    Total

    176

    2.6973

    .27055

     

     

     

    Table 14

    Results of ANOVA on teaching experience-wise Differences 

     


    The seventh hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the teaching experience of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed insignificant teaching experience-wise differences in all the research variables (coping strategy, occupational stress and mental health). The p-values for all the variables (coping strategies= .319, occupational stress= .067, and mental health= .286) were found greater than the critical value (p > 0.05). It means that lecturers having different age groups reported no statistically significant differences of opinion regarding variables under study. Based on these results, the set hypothesis H7 is strongly rejected.

    Variables

    Experience

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    F

    df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    1-5 Years

    10

    2.3460

    .29785

    1.186

    171

    .319

    6-10 Years

    18

    2.5967

    .36345

    11-15 Years

    67

    2.4693

    .32651

    16-20 Years

    47

    2.4496

    .22122

    21-25 Years

    34

    2.4653

    .36337

    Total

    176

    2.4693

    .31306

     

     

     

    Occupational Stress

    1-5 Years

    10

    2.8930

    .28158

    2.236

    171

    .067

    6-10 Years

    18

    2.6772

    .36514

    11-15 Years

    67

    2.6554

    .34653

    16-20 Years

    47

    2.5928

    .20431

    21-25 Years

    34

    2.6409

    .22976

    Total

    176

    2.6516

    .29597

     

     

     

    Mental Health

    1-5 Years

    10

    2.8710

    .25497

    1.265

    171

    .286

    6-10 Years

    18

    2.6872

    .33478

    11-15 Years

    67

    2.6931

    .31164

    16-20 Years

    47

    2.6619

    .20244

    21-25 Years

    34

    2.7088

    .22404

    Total

    176

    2.6973

    .27055

     

     

     

    Table 15

    Results of ANOVA on education level-wise Differences  


    The eighth hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the education levels of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed significant differences based on different levels of education regarding the research variables except for coping strategy. The p-values for all the variables except coping strategy were found greater than the critical value (p > 0.05). Based on these results, the set hypothesis H8 is partially accepted. 

    Variables

    Experience

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    F

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    B.S

    `38

    2.4537

    .36698

    3.021

    172

    .031

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.4161

    .29159

    M. Phil

    47

    2.5823

    .29281

    Ph. D

    4

    2.4450

    .13379

    Total

    176

    2.4693

    .31306

     

     

     

    Occupational Stress

    B.S

    38

    2.6292

    .30028

    .864

    172

    .461

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.6809

    .30409

    M. Phil

    47

    2.6296

    .28714

    Ph. D

    4

    2.4850

    .08347

    Total

    176

    2.6516

    .29597

     

     

     

    Mental Health

    B.S

    38

    2.6808

    .26336

    .824

    172

    .482

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.7257

    .28011

    M. Phil

    47

    2.6687

    .26583

    Ph. D

    4

    2.5725

    .14569

    Total

    176

    2.6973

    .27055

     

     

     

    Table 15

    Results of ANOVA on education level-wise Differences  


    The eighth hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the education levels of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed significant differences based on different levels of education regarding the research variables except for coping strategy. The p-values for all the variables except coping strategy were found greater than the critical value (p > 0.05). Based on these results, the set hypothesis H8 is partially accepted. 

    Variables

    Experience

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    F

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    B.S

    `38

    2.4537

    .36698

    3.021

    172

    .031

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.4161

    .29159

    M. Phil

    47

    2.5823

    .29281

    Ph. D

    4

    2.4450

    .13379

    Total

    176

    2.4693

    .31306

     

     

     

    Occupational Stress

    B.S

    38

    2.6292

    .30028

    .864

    172

    .461

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.6809

    .30409

    M. Phil

    47

    2.6296

    .28714

    Ph. D

    4

    2.4850

    .08347

    Total

    176

    2.6516

    .29597

     

     

     

    Mental Health

    B.S

    38

    2.6808

    .26336

    .824

    172

    .482

    M.A/ M.Sc.

    87

    2.7257

    .28011

    M. Phil

    47

    2.6687

    .26583

    Ph. D

    4

    2.5725

    .14569

    Total

    176

    2.6973

    .27055

     

     

     

    Table 16

    Results of ANOVA on Nature of Job-wise Differences 


    The last hypothesis was formulated to check the groups' mean differences based on the nature of the job of the respondents. The analyzed inferences showed significant differences based on the nature of the job of lecturers regarding the research variables except for coping strategy. The p-values for all the variables except coping strategy were found greater than the critical value (p > 0.05). Based on these results, the set hypothesis H9 is partially accepted.

    Variables

    Nature of Job

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    F

    Df

    Sig. (2-tailed)

    Coping Strategies

    Physical Edu. Teacher

    57

    2.4437

    .32122

    5.701

    173

    .004

    Arts Teacher

    78

    2.4149

    .29821

    Science Teacher

    41

    2.6083

    .29432

    Total

    176

    2.4693

    .31306

     

     

     

    Occupational Stress

    Physical Edu. Teacher

    57

    2.5904

    .28284

    1.938

    173

    .147

    Arts Teacher

    78

    2.6903

    .30497

    Science Teacher

    41

    2.6632

    .28951

    Total

    176

    2.6516

    .29597

     

     

     

    Mental Health

    Physical Edu. Teacher

    57

    2.6507

    .24691

    1.556

    173

    .214

    Arts Teacher

    78

    2.7335

    .28358

    Science Teacher

    41

    2.6934

    .27283

    Total

    176

    2.6973

    .27055

     

     

     

    Discussion

    Research in the relevant area has found that the teaching community reported enormous occupational stress and poor mental health in comparison with other professions (Ahola et al., 2014; Bauer et al., 2014; Havermans et al., 2016). In the current study, occupational stress, mental health and copying styles of the college teachers in Southern Punjab, Pakistan were examined. When comparing two different genders, the analyzed data indicates that female lecturers were facing higher reported higher mean scores on occupational stress, mental health, and copying style as compared with male lecturers.  These findings corroborate previous results reporting that there was a positive relationship between occupational stress and mental health in various working populace (Feyer et al., 2000). The same findings have been reported from other results indicating mental health problems in the teaching community (Chiu & Lam, 2007; Korkmaz, Cavlak, & Telci, 2011; Nurul et al., 2010). Poor mental health in relation to occupational stress in the teaching community is indeed not a new phenomenon. It is researched that female teachers experience more occupational stress and health problems as compared with male teachers. In the current study, male college teachers reported lesser occupational stress when compared with female lecturers. These findings, therefore, corroborated with some previous studies where female teachers reported significantly higher mean scores on occupational stress and mental health issues (Bíró, Ádány, &Kósa, 2011; Stallman, 2010).

    However, the current study indicated that married and unmarried lecturers reported no statistically significant differences of opinion regarding the variables under study. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was applied to examine the group mean differences based on Age, teaching experience, qualifications, and respective field of profession among college teachers. The analyzed inferences further showed significant age-wise differences in all the research variables except coping strategy.  Moreover, the results of the current study revealed insignificant teaching experience-wise differences in all the research variables (coping strategy, occupational stress and mental health). The analyzed inferences showed significant differences based on different levels of education regarding the research variables except for coping strategy. The analyzed inferences showed significant differences based on the nature of the job of lecturers regarding the research variables except for coping strategy. Past results revealed that on a personal level, it is often the case that an individual is unable to deal with the job load and surroundings, which results in a negative expression. Teaching is often seen as high-stress work when compared to teaching experience (Edwards & Burnard, 2003).

    Conclusion

    The analyzed data indicates that female lecturers were facing higher reported higher mean scores on occupational stress, mental health, and copying style as compared with male lecturers.  The current study has several limitations that need to be highlighted. The first limitation of the current study is that the researcher used cross-sectional data from the southern region of Punjab, Pakistan. Longitudinal studies are strongly recommended; however, longitudinal studies need a larger financial budget and time too that were not available for the present research work. The second limitation deals with college-level professionals as occupational stress may vary among professions, therefore; the findings of the current study may not be generalized to other professions such as schools and universities. 

    Recommendations

    To enhance the mental health of the teaching community in general and lecturer in particular, those interventional programs may be established within institutional organizations both at regional and national levels that help them assist to reduce distress and to promote copying skills to deal with their critical incidents on their work. Hence, future research may deal with how to develop such an interventional program and also to evaluate the effectiveness of these programs to promote and develop mental health and work performance of the teaching community.

    One-day workshops and seminars on managing work-related stress must be conducted on a regular basis to train them on how to deal with occupational stress. Physical recreational activities must be encouraged in the workplace as these activities proved very helpful in improving mental health and reducing stress (Rippentrop et al., 2005; Skaalvik&Skaalvik, 2011).

    Recommendations

    To enhance the mental health of the teaching community in general and lecturer in particular, those interventional programs may be established within institutional organizations both at regional and national levels that help them assist to reduce distress and to promote copying skills to deal with their critical incidents on their work. Hence, future research may deal with how to develop such an interventional program and also to evaluate the effectiveness of these programs to promote and develop mental health and work performance of the teaching community.

    One-day workshops and seminars on managing work-related stress must be conducted on a regular basis to train them on how to deal with occupational stress. Physical recreational activities must be encouraged in the workplace as these activities proved very helpful in improving mental health and reducing stress (Rippentrop et al., 2005; Skaalvik&Skaalvik, 2011).

References

  • Abbasi, T. F. (2015). Impact of Work Overload on Stress, Job Satisfaction, and Turnover Intentions with Moderating Role of Islamic Work Ethics. Management Studies and Economic Systems, 2(1), 27–37.
  • Acquadro Maran, D., Zedda, M., & Varetto, A. (2018). Organizational and Occupational Stressors, Their Consequences and Coping Strategies: A Questionnaire Survey among Italian Patrol Police Officers. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 15(1), 166.
  • Ahola, K., Hakanen, J., Perhoniemi, R., & Mutanen, P. (2014). Relationship between burnout and depressive symptoms: A study using the person-centred approach. Burnout Research, 1(1), 29–37.
  • Bauer, G. F., Hämmig, O., Cartwright, S., & Cooper, C. L. (2014). Towards Organizational Health: Stress, Positive Organizational Behavior, and Employee Well-Being. Bridging Occupational, Organizational and Public Health, 29–42. .
  • Bíró, É., Ádány, R., & Kósa, K. (2011). Mental health and behaviour of students of public health and their correlation with social support: a cross-sectional study. BMC Public Health, 11(1). .
  • Carpenter, G. I. (2006). Accuracy, validity and reliability in assessment and in evaluation of services for older people: the role of the inter RAI MDS assessment system. Age and Ageing, 35(4), 327-329.
  • Chiu, T. T. W., & Lam, P. K. W. (2006). The Prevalence of and Risk Factors for Neck Pain and Upper Limb Pain among Secondary School Teachers in Hong Kong. Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 17(1), 19–32.
  • Edwards, D., & Burnard, P. (2003). A systematic review of stress and stress management interventions for mental health nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 42(2), 169–200.
  • Fard, P. G., & Karimi, F. (2015). The Relationship between Organizational Trust and Organizational Silence with Job Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment of the Employees of University. International Education Studies, 8(11), 219.
  • Feyer, A.-M. . (2000). The role of physical and psychological factors in occupational low back pain: a prospective cohort study. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 57(2), 116–120.

Cite this article

    APA : Aslam, M., Nawaz, M., & Kanwal, S. (2023). Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab. Global Social Sciences Review, VIII(I), 309-321. https://doi.org/10.31703/gssr.2023(VIII-I).28
    CHICAGO : Aslam, Muhammad, Muhammad Nawaz, and Sumaira Kanwal. 2023. "Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab." Global Social Sciences Review, VIII (I): 309-321 doi: 10.31703/gssr.2023(VIII-I).28
    HARVARD : ASLAM, M., NAWAZ, M. & KANWAL, S. 2023. Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab. Global Social Sciences Review, VIII, 309-321.
    MHRA : Aslam, Muhammad, Muhammad Nawaz, and Sumaira Kanwal. 2023. "Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab." Global Social Sciences Review, VIII: 309-321
    MLA : Aslam, Muhammad, Muhammad Nawaz, and Sumaira Kanwal. "Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab." Global Social Sciences Review, VIII.I (2023): 309-321 Print.
    OXFORD : Aslam, Muhammad, Nawaz, Muhammad, and Kanwal, Sumaira (2023), "Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab", Global Social Sciences Review, VIII (I), 309-321
    TURABIAN : Aslam, Muhammad, Muhammad Nawaz, and Sumaira Kanwal. "Assessment of Occupational Stress Mental Health and Copying Style among Colleges’ Teachers based on Selected Demographic Attributes: A Case Study of Southern Districts of Punjab." Global Social Sciences Review VIII, no. I (2023): 309-321. https://doi.org/10.31703/gssr.2023(VIII-I).28